The Daily Forehand: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Login-facebook
Around SBN: College Football Preseason Top 25 Rankings

Shout Knocks Serena Out

Serena Williams in her press conference, via d.yimg.com

Serena Williams in her press conference, via d.yimg.com

Suffice it to say that after the last point contested in her US Open semifinal vs. Kim Clijsters, Serena Williams was anything but serene.

Serving to stay in a match in which she was being outplayed, Serena Williams was a woman battling.  It was a battle against Kim Clijsters, an unseeded player in her first grand slam in over two years, playing some of the best tennis of her career. It was a battle against history, as a win would put her a match away from tying Billie Jean King's mark of twelve career slams.  And it was a battle against her own nerves, which had become somewhat shakier as double faults crept into her game in the second set.

But with all the battles she was fighting, Serena saved her most vicious attack for a small, bespectacled lineswoman who sat monitoring the right baseline.

13e8e3282faba312ea056d3d3d098fa7-getty-83372613md071_us_open_day_1_medium

The lineswoman's offense? She called a foot fault on a second serve at 15-30 in 5-6 in the second set, thereby giving Clijsters two match points and sending shockwaves through the crowd.

Serena turned to the ball kid for new balls and appeared to collect herself for a moment, but then turned to the lineswoman and went on a screaming, racquet shaking assault.

Here is what CBS audio was able to pick up, before boos drowned out the end of the tirade:

"I swear to God I'll fucking take this ball and shove it down your fucking throat! Do you hear me? I swear to God. You better be glad--you better be fucking glad that I'm not, I swear."

The chair umpire summoned the lineswoman to the chair, where she reported what Serena had said.  The chair umpire called tournament referee Brian Earley and official Donna Kelso to the court, where they conferred with the chair umpire, lineswoman, and Serena, and determined that a code violation would be assessed.  Since Serena had already been given a warning at the end of the first set for smashing a racquet, this second offense was to result in a point penalty.  And since the next point was a match point, the point penalty gave Clijsters the match.

Serena walked to the far side of the court, shook a reluctant Clijsters' hand, and calmly left the court with her things, waving to the crowd, who was either booing her conduct or the decision.  Perhaps both.

Efacd17a12a48a3512a3cc5b54f501cf-getty-83372613tl006_us_open_day_1_medium

The targeted lineswoman deserves a ton of credit for her conduct throughout the entire incident.  She firmly called a foot fault when she believed a foot fault had been committed, which is exactly what is her duty.  She was unfazed by the situation in the match, as she should have been.  A foot fault is a black-and-white call, and for her not to have made it because she was daunted by the occasion would have been a disservice to her duty.  She did not flinch in the face of Serena's rage, nor did she lash back at her.  She explained to the chair umpire what happened when asked, and quietly left the court when all was said and done.  Whatever your name is, lineswoman, I salute you.

For someone who had just unleashed a verbal chainsaw on a petite, glasses-wearing woman trying to do her job to the best of her abilities, Serena was remarkably bubbly in her press conference.  She smiled, laughed, gave copious amounts of credit to Clijsters for her play, and seemed to be in better spirits than she ever has been after being eliminated from a grand slam.  The about-face was stunning, and almost frightening.

Serena even admitted in her press conference that she probably had committed a foot fault, a fact she never did dispute in her upbraiding of the woman.  Whether she wanted to intimidate, bully, embarrass, or merely vent her frustration, Serena's motivation was clearly never to question the veracity of the call.

The question now is whether or not Serena will be further punished for her actions.  She could be fined by the WTA, ITF, or even USTA for her profanity and threats of violence, though they may decide losing a grand slam semifinal was punishment enough.

Do you think Serena should face further consequences for her actions? Vote in the poll, then explain your vote in the comments.

After the jump, embedded video of the incident.

Star-divide

 

Poll
Should Serena face further sanctions for her outburst?
Yes
37 votes
No
12 votes

49 votes | Poll has closed

0 recs  |  Comment 18 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Aaaa...

I am going to start out by saying I disagree with just about everything. That is the least threatening lines person ever, though. I agree mostly with this article: here by Tom Perrotta.

Anywhoo, you start off by using a Mary Carillo line (serene-Serena). -1 Any who knows if Serena could’ve held if it wasn’t for an atrocious foot call. And a tiebreak can be a flip of a coin, so who knows.

Yes the call was atrocious in my opinion. It was a fraction of an inch and why call it there? If this was football/basketball people would be screaming, “Let the players goddamn play!” I usually view foot faults as a ‘message call’ , if you will, like you call it to send a message, “we’re enforcing foot faults.” Its not something you just throw around at 15-30 , 5-6. And defiantly not on a second serve. Letter of the law, not spirit sort of thing.

The thing that really bugged me about this call was that was the first time she foot faulted in the match. It’s not like she was chronically foot faulting like her sister or Sharapova earlier.

And if you, or anyone, believe Serena should be fined, I think McEnroe & Connors owe you about 2 million dollars in back fines. (I voted No on the poll by the way- and I’d like to vote No about a hundred times).

by Jsz on Sep 13, 2009 9:45 AM EDT reply actions  

bullshit

Foot-faulting is not a difficult concept: her foot was either on the line before the serve or it wasn’t. This isn’t obstruction interference in overtime in the NHL, where you can make an argument either way. The notion that, because “this was the first time she foot faulted in the match. It’s not like she was chronically foot faulting like her sister or Sharapova earlier”, is totally irrelevant. She foot-faulted according to the person with the best angle on her foot and the baseline. She foot-faults frequently, context is irrelevant. It’s the rule and it’s a legit, good rule. If she did indeed foot fault as the line-judge said, then the ONLY course of action is to call that foot fault as the line-judge did.

And yes she should be fined and possibly suspended for a couple weeks. Fuck that was borderline assault. Because Mac and Connors acted stupid 30 years ago, in a shock-value era of tennis doesn’t justify shit. Remember Mac witnessed a transition, he got his ass DQ’d in a major, that was enough pay-back for me.

by lcollins1 on Sep 13, 2009 1:27 PM EDT up reply actions  

I agree and she was called for a foot fault earlier in the match

I don’t know if they will do it but she should be suspended for a period to teach her a lesson in court manners. She will be lucky if that lady doesn’t sue her because if that is what she said that is an slander. The whole thing is that Serena has become the I am above all in tennis and thats not good for the game, especially the WTA which doesn’t draw that good except for majors.

Well I guess KIM is the best player now!

Paul D. Kelley
Come as you are not who you pretend to be!
You are only as good as your 2nd serve and 1st volley

by so.cal.native1952 on Sep 13, 2009 1:51 PM EDT up reply actions  

For a guy mad about a tirade, you seem angry yourself :)

If she was called for a FF earlier than I am wrong about that and that part of my argument is irrelevant.

I do believe context is important there. The rule is to prevent the server from having an unfair advantage? Do you really think that fraction gave Serena an unfair advantage.

And she shouldn’t get suspended. I don’t quite understand what you mean by “Mac witnessed a transition.” And it’s not just Johnny, but more modern people such as Haas and Safin.

Serena did not do the right thing. Defiantly not. I’m not saying she did But given the circumstances, its not indefensible. And yes, the circumstances are important for a call such as this, because you don’t play tennis in a perfect vacuum.

by Jsz on Sep 13, 2009 2:30 PM EDT up reply actions  

Here's my concern:

This is not an arguable, call it sometimes, call it differently thing like defensive pass-interference in the NFL. I don’t know, but I don’t think this rule has changed in over 100 years. It’s a rule of fairness, to the game and to the player on the other side of the net. Grand-slam tennis can come down to micro-fibers on a digital review, therefore, I think a couple of inches is a significant advantage. And, If you start allowing people to step over the line, where does it end?

What I mean by ‘Mac witnessed a transition’ is that he began his career in an era of tennis when berating an official was ok. He took it to another level, he attracted fans, in part because of his tirades. He still does it in World Team Tennis and the Masters Tour. In fact, it’s part of his shtick, people expect it out of him when they buy the tickets.

However, at the end of his ATP career, he got disqualified from the Australian Open in the middle of a match. What happened was that pro tennis had shifted to a higher level of officiating, sportsmanship and expectation from its players. Mac had not shifted and he got sent off on one of the biggest stages in the world. His shtick was no longer acceptable in the modern ATP, and Serena’s isn’t acceptable on the modern WTA tour either. Suspend her, fine her, send a message.

by lcollins1 on Sep 13, 2009 3:13 PM EDT up reply actions  

Ok, I understand your point. My opinion is different, and clearly we won’t be able to convince each other.

I’m not saying stand right up at the net and serve, I’m saying at a tiny infraction at 15-30 don’t call it. I think you know I’m not really saying step over the line whenever you want… My point is the linesperson ended up deciding the match, not Kim and Serena. Maybe they could’ve applied the point in the potential tiebreak, and the not on Match point. I wouldn’t have a problem with that.

I only take issue with “Suspend her, fine her, send a message.” I don’t really believe in people being ‘messages’ unless they committed actual legal crimes (whole different issue though). And didn’t you say “This isn’t obstruction interference in overtime in the NHL, where you can make an argument either way.” Well you can make an argument either way if what she did was unacceptable or not. So how is this so different?

Anywhoo we’re not gonna convince each other so whatevah.

by Jsz on Sep 13, 2009 3:40 PM EDT up reply actions  

Her actions with the racket and the proximity were borderline legal assault. Not battery, but assault.

Serena decided the match when she assaulted the line-judge and prior to that when she committed a foot-fault, line-judge did nothing but enforcement. If you want to take issue with the rule, write some letters to the WTA, USTA, ITA, NCAA, ATP, maybe they’d listen to your argument. I doubt it, but maybe.

It’s not about ‘acceptable or not’ it’s about a deeply-rooted rule with strong policy reasons behind it.

Yea I’m about done…

by lcollins1 on Sep 13, 2009 3:50 PM EDT up reply actions  

I’m not gonna argue anymore. Just wanna say although we completely disagree the level of conversation here is much better than any other internet site I’ve found. No name-calling here, either. Although the internet sets low standards.

by Jsz on Sep 13, 2009 4:21 PM EDT up reply actions  

agreed. I actually posted on the “Uncommon Sportsman” a couple months back asking about a tennis site like this.

Glad it’s here…

by lcollins1 on Sep 13, 2009 4:24 PM EDT up reply actions  

Thanks, glad to have you here as well. Anybody who lists Eric Butorac as one of their favorites clearly knows a thing or two about the sport.

The Daily Forehand -- SB Nation's Tennis Destination.
Broad Street Hockey.

by Ben Rothenberg on Sep 13, 2009 4:32 PM EDT up reply actions  

McEnroe's a clown

I thought McEnroe was a total rubberhead last night. He claimed that ‘this never should have happened to begin with’ because there was no foot fault. Really? Because from the only angle I could see it was certainly inconclusive. Was McEnroe’s angle from about 500 feet better than all of the telecast’s I’ve seen?

The tirade is indefensible and worthy of a point penalty under any circumstances, and this is coming from a guy who pumped faked an official on the hand-shake after a match once upon a bitter time.

I just think McEnroe acted like an ignorant fool. The bottom line is the line-judge had the angle on the call. How is McEnroe going to sit in the booth and make a concrete determination to the contrary?

by lcollins1 on Sep 13, 2009 1:22 PM EDT reply actions  

I have always liked JMs game but his tirades are inexcusable you would think he would be more like his bro.

Paul D. Kelley
Come as you are not who you pretend to be!
You are only as good as your 2nd serve and 1st volley

by so.cal.native1952 on Sep 13, 2009 1:54 PM EDT up reply actions  

Also Serena never admits the she got beat but I played badly or I didn't have my A or B game last night against Kim

Basically she has know sportsmanship (more of Sportsmanshit) in a game that is all about that very ordeal. I heard Lindsey say that Williams has a book coming out please people don’t buy it.

Paul D. Kelley
Come as you are not who you pretend to be!
You are only as good as your 2nd serve and 1st volley

by so.cal.native1952 on Sep 13, 2009 1:59 PM EDT reply actions  

Serena is definitely not always the most gracious loser, but this was an exception. She was extremely praising of Kim afterwards.

The Daily Forehand -- SB Nation's Tennis Destination.
Broad Street Hockey.

by Ben Rothenberg on Sep 13, 2009 4:33 PM EDT up reply actions  

Yah I guess she was better but I did detect the Williams Attitude in the background.

The reason I am hard on the Williams attitude is I saw them and have hit with them at a WTA tourny back when they were 7 and 9. Their father was trying to get my best friend and just about any local teaching pro to help coach them for free.

Secondly when they played juniors they were suspended for a season then the old man decided we will not play. They are not well liked in the southern Cal tennis Community, but thats beside the point that they still show there un sportmanship to others.

Paul D. Kelley
Come as you are not who you pretend to be!
You are only as good as your 2nd serve and 1st volley

by so.cal.native1952 on Sep 13, 2009 5:09 PM EDT up reply actions  

NFL, NBA, MLB

These sports are not know for near the class as tennis. They are full of tempers, fights and loudmouths. Then there are the people who play the games. If any of those players talks to an official like that they would face a suspension. Tennis, I believe, is a higher level of sophistication than those sports, and should at least do the same. Remember, this was her second unsportsmanlike conduct of the match.

by dakotajim on Sep 15, 2009 8:23 AM EDT reply actions  

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

SB Nation's Tennis Destination.
Start posting on The Daily Forehand »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

Connect_with_facebook

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recent FanPosts

Associated_20press_clayliston_1965_l_small
Who Can Win the Open (men)?
Livan_hernandez_articlepopup_small
Rogers Cup Preview
Small
Some advice to Mary Joe Fernandez
Livan_hernandez_articlepopup_small
Who will win the Legg Mason Tennis Classic?
Livan_hernandez_articlepopup_small
Enter the US Open Series Draw Challenge for the Farmers Classic
Bikes_008_small
Maria Sharapova is falling off the edge
Rclwimb_small
Melanie Oudin Plays in her Hometown - In a Circuit Event
Livan_hernandez_articlepopup_small
The Atlanta Tennis Championships Draw Challenge
Livan_hernandez_articlepopup_small
Daily Forehand US Open Series
Rclwimb_small
How Vera Zvonareva can beat Serena

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SBNation.com Recent Stories

NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 02:  Roger Federer of Switzerland returns a shot to Andreas Beck of Germany during the Men's singles on day four of the 2010 U.S. Open at the USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center on September 2 2010 in the Flushing neighborhood of the Queens borough of New York City.  (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images) +12 updates

2010 U.S. Open, Day 4: Federer, Wozniacki Make It Look Easy, Djokovic Continues Reign Of Comedic Terror

NEW YORK - SEPTEMBER 01: Andy Roddick of the United States reacts after a point against Janko Tipsarevic of Serbia during his second round men's singles match on day three of the 2010 U.S. Open at the USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center on September 1 2010 in the Flushing neighborhood of the Queens borough of New York City.  (Photo by Al Bello/Getty Images) +14 updates

Failure In Flushing: Andy Roddick Falls In Second Round Of U.S. Open

NEW YORK - AUGUST 31:  Rafael Nadal of Spain returns a shot against Teymuraz Gabashvili of Russia during his first round men's single's match on day two of the 2010 U.S. Open at the USTA Billie Jean King National Tennis Center on August 31 2010 in the Flushing neighborhood of the Queens borough of New York City.  (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) +11 updates

2010 U.S. Open Day 2: Favorites Roll Despite Tough Early Tests

More from SBNation.com >


Managers

Me_minus_kbond_small Ben Rothenberg

Editors

Rclwimb_small Rick Limpert